top of page

SEVEN/FIFTY
The Centre for Constitutional Studies Blog
A hub for current constitutional dialogue and commentary in Canada and beyond
Recent Posts


Why Care About Who's Paramount? Explaining the Doctrine of Federal Paramountcy, Part 1
This is Part 1 of a two-part article exploring the doctrine of federal paramountcy, which is on the ballot in Alberta’s October 2026 referendum. In this first part, I explain the constitutional context needed to understand the doctrine, and Alberta’s objection to it. Then, in Part 2, I advance the argument that federal paramountcy is an important and indeed required component of Canada’s federal system. Introduction On October 19, 2026, Alberta is scheduled to hold a province
Alexis Vander Linden
Oct 710 min read


Canada’s Electoral System Upheld as Constitutional in Fair Voting BC v Canada (Attorney General)
The Canadian electoral system survived a constitutional challenge at the Ontario Court of Appeal, with the Court unanimously holding that the Single Member Plurality electoral system (“SMP” or “first-past-the-post”) does not violate voting or equality rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.[1] This article provides a quick breakdown of the challenge and the Court’s reasoning in response to it. Background Since Confederation in 1867, Canada has used an SM
Anjali Choudhary
Oct 25 min read


You Can't Have it Both Ways: Why the Courts Must Recognize the Right of Self-Government as Included in Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982
Let us start at the beginning — what makes a right a right? Your rights are really only rights if they serve to protect activities that you want to engage in. If you want to say something controversial in public, the constitutional guarantee of freedom of expression allows you to do that, as it is your right to. If you were a hermit, though, and never saw anyone else who you could say something to, the fact that freedom of expression is a constitutional right would be irrelev
Ian Peach
Sep 253 min read
Search


Why Care About Who's Paramount? Explaining the Doctrine of Federal Paramountcy, Part 1
This is Part 1 of a two-part article exploring the doctrine of federal paramountcy, which is on the ballot in Alberta’s October 2026 referendum. In this first part, I explain the constitutional context needed to understand the doctrine, and Alberta’s objection to it. Then, in Part 2, I advance the argument that federal paramountcy is an important and indeed required component of Canada’s federal system. Introduction On October 19, 2026, Alberta is scheduled to hold a province
Alexis Vander Linden
Oct 710 min read


How Did We Get to a Referendum Question on Separation? Mapping the Legal Journey of the Citizen Initiative Petitions in Alberta
This article serves as Part I of an explainer on the legal developments surrounding the various Alberta separatism petitions that have dominated headlines in recent months. Part I covers the timeline of Mr. Sylvestre’s petitions, the Forever Canadian Petition, and the relevant amendments that have been made to the law governing citizen petitions in Alberta, the Citizen Initiative Act. Subsequently, Parts II and III will dissect Justice Leonard’s May 13, 2026, decision in Atha
Kiera Fischer
Aug 2713 min read


Proposed Referendum Question on Alberta Independence Found Unlawful in Chief Electoral Officer of Alberta v Sylvestre
It looks increasingly likely that Albertans will be voting on whether to separate from Canada this year. This vote would not only pose an existential challenge to the entire country, but has also been found to contravene certain constitutional rights by Justice Colin Feasby (Alberta Court of King’s Bench) in Chief Electoral Officer of Alberta v Sylvestre . [1] The effect of this ruling has been limited, however, by Alberta’s Justice Statutes Amendment Act, 2025 (“Bill 14”),
Anjali Choudhary
Apr 99 min read


A Provincial Role in Judicial Appointments: Turning a Reasonable Request into a Poison Pill?
Late last month Alberta Premier Danielle Smith sent Prime Minister Mark Carney a letter, made public in the first week of February, seeking a role for the Alberta government in the selection of federally-appointed judges. [1] This is a reasonable request. Indeed, my understanding is that it has generally been common practice for the federal Justice Minister to seek the opinion of their provincial counterpart from the province for which they would be appointing a judge (as we
Ian Peach
Feb 247 min read
bottom of page